Ice adhesion. Methods of determination (review)

Marchenko S.A., Zheleznyak V.G., Kuznetsova V.A.
UDC
539.612
DOI
10.18577/2307-6046-2022-0-9-143-160
Article PDF (Russian) (922.99 KB)
How to cite
Marchenko S.A., Zheleznyak V.G., Kuznetsova V.A. Ice adhesion. Methods of determination (review) // Proceedings of VIAM. 2022. No. 9. DOI: 10.18577/2307-6046-2022-0-9-143-160. URL: https://test.viam.ru/en/journal/2022/9/12
Keywords
ice adhesion, aircraft icing, shear adhesion strength, centrifugal force method, tensile adhesion strength, supercooled water droplets
Abstract

Currently, to determine the degree of de-icing protection when using anti-icing coatings, experimental benches and laboratory installations are used, in which in most cases two types of tests are performed: direct mechanical and centrifugal force. The variety of methods, facilities, and other various factors makes it difficult to compare the established data and the required characteristics of anti-icing properties of coatings. An analysis of the methods and installations used to determine ice adhesion, as well as the factors that can affect the test results, has been conducted.

Reference list
  1. Venkataramani K., McVey L., Holm R., Montgomery K. Inclement weather considerations for aircraft engines. 45th Aerospace sciences meeting and exhibit. Reno, Nevada, 2007, pp. 695.
  2. Kablov E.N. Aviation materials science in the XXI century. Prospects and tasks. Aviation materials. Selected works of VIAM 1932–2002. Moscow: MISIS; VIAM, 2002, pp. 23–47.
  3. Abramova M.G., Lutsenko A.N., Varchenko E.A. Concerning the aspects of validation of climate resistance of airborne materials at all life cycle stages (review). Aviacionnye materialy i tehnologii, 2020, no. 1 (58), pp. 86–94. DOI: 10.18577/2071-9140-2020-0-1-86-94.
  4. Ignatyev D.I., Khrabrov A.N., Kortukova A.I. et al. Interplay of unsteady aerodynamics and flight dynamics of transport aircraft in icing conditions. Aerospace Science and Technology, 2020, vol. 104, pp. 105914.
  5. Huang X., Tepylo N., Pommier-Budinger V. et al. A survey of icephobic coatings and their potential use in a hybrid coating/active ice protection system for aerospace applications. Progress in Aerospace Sciences, 2019, vol. 105, pp. 74–97.
  6. Cebeci T., Kafyeke F. Aircrafticing. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics, 2003, vol. 35 (1), pp. 11–21.
  7. Kablov E.N., Startsev V.O. Systematical analysis of the climatics influence on mechanical properties of the polymer composite materials based on domestic and foreign sources (review). Aviacionnye materialy i tehnologii, 2018, no. 2 (51), pp. 47–58. DOI: 10.18577/2071-9140-2018-0-2-47-58.
  8. Lynch F.T., Khodadoust A. Effects of Ice Accretions on aircraft Aerodynamics. Progress in Aerospace Sciences, 2001, vol. 37, pp. 669–767.
  9. Airworthiness directives. Boeing aircraft. Federal Register, 2016, vol. 81, no. 78, pp. 23581–23586.
  10. Mason J., Strapp J., Chow P. The Ice Particle Threat to Engines in Flight. 45th Aerospace sciences meeting and exhibit. Reno, Nevada, 2006, p. 206.
  11. Kamel M. Al-Khalil, Theo G. Keith, Kenneth J. De Witt. Icing calculations on a typical commercial jet engine inlet nacelle. Journal of Aircraft, 1997, vol. 34, no. 1, pp. 87.
  12. Zheng M., Guo Z., Dong W., Guo X. Experimental investigation on ice accretion on a rotating aero-engine spinner with hydrophobic coating. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 2019, vol. 136, pp. 404–414.
  13. Palacios A.M., Palacios J.L., Sánchez L. Eliciting a human understandable model of ice adhesion strength for rotor blade leading edge materials from uncertain experimental data. Expert Systems with Applications, 2012, vol. 39, pp. 10212–10225.
  14. Flight in icing conditions: AC 91-74B – Pilot Guide. 2015. Available at: https://www.faa.gov/regulations_policies/advisory_circulars/index.cfm/go/document.information/documentid/1028388 (accessed: March 19, 2022).
  15. Zhang Z., Liu X. Control of ice nucleation: freezing and antifreeze strategies. Chemical Society Reviews, 2018, vol. 47, pp. 7116–39.
  16. Li Q., Guo Z. Fundamentals of icing and common strategies for designing biomimetic anti-icing surfaces. Journal of Materials Chemistry, 2018, vol. 6, pp. 13549–13581.
  17. Zheng H.K., Chang S.N., Zhao Y.Y. Anti-icing and icephobic mechanism and applications of superhydrophobic/ultra slippery surface. Progress in Chemistry, 2017, vol. 29 (1), pp. 102–118.
  18. Tarasova P.N., Sleptsova S.A., Laukkanen S., Dyakonov A.A. Sealing materials based on polytetrafluo-roethylene for aviation products. Aviation materials and technologies, 2022, no. 1 (66), paper no. 05. Available at: http://www.journal.viam.ru (ассеssed: March 24, 2022). DOI: 10.18577/2713-0193-2022-0-1-51-64.
  19. Solovyanchik L.V., Pykhtin A.A., Vednikova V.S., Kondrashov S.V., Pavlyuk B.F. Investigation of the effect of silicon dioxide nanoparticles on the surface properties of organosilicon coatings. Rossiyskiye nanotekhnologii, 2019, vol. 14, pp. 31–36.
  20. Kondrashov S.V., Shashkeev K.A., Petrova G.N., Mekalina I.V. Constructional polymer composites with functional properties. Aviacionnye materialy i tehnologii, 2017, no. S, pp. 405–419. DOI: 10.18577/2071-9140-2017-0-S-405-419.
  21. Buznik V.M., Kablov E.N. Materials for the development of the Arctic and cold territories. Reports of XXI Mendeleev Congress on General and Applied Chemistry: in 6 vols. St. Petersburg, 2019, vol. 4, p. 21.
  22. Yang S., Xia Q., Zhu L. et al. Research on the icephobic properties of fluoropolymer-based materials. Applied Surface Science, 2011, vol. 257, pp. 4956–4962.
  23. Golovin K., Kobaku S.P.R., Lee D.H. et al. Designing durable icephobic surfaces. Science Advances, 2016, vol. 2, pp. 1–12.
  24. Hakimian A., Nazifi S., Ghasemi H. Ice Adhesion: Mechanism, Measurement and Mitigation. Metrology of Ice Adhesion. Scrivener Publishing LLC, 2020, pp. 217–236. DOI: 10.1002/9781119640523.ch8.
  25. Rönneberg S., He J., Zhang Z. The need for standards in low ice adhesion surface research: a critical review. Journal of Adhesion Science and Technology, 2019, vol. 34 (3), pp. 319–347.
  26. Bleszynski M., Clark E. Current Ice Adhesion Testing Methods and the Need for a Standard: A Concise Review October. Standards, 2021, vol. 1 (2), pp. 117–133.
  27. Parent O., Ilinca A. Anti-icing and de-icing techniques for wind turbines: Critical review. Cold Regions Science and Technology, 2011, vol. 65, pp. 88–96.
  28. Sojoudi H., Wang M., Boscher N.D. et al. Durable and scalable icephobic surfaces: similarity and distinctions from superhydrophobic surfaces. Soft Matter, 2016, vol. 12, pp. 1938–1963.
  29. Fortin G., Laforte J., Ilinca A. Heat and mass transfer during ice accretion on aircraft wings with an improved roughness model. International Journal of Thermal Sciences, 2006, vol. 45, pp. 595–606.
  30. Amendola A., Mingione G. On the problem of icing for modern civil aircraft. Air & Space Europe, 2001, vol. 3 (3/4), pp. 214–217.
  31. Zhang C., Liu H. Effect of drop size on the impact thermodynamics for supercooled large droplet in aircraft icing. Physics of Fluids, 2016, vol. 28, pp. 062107.
  32. Lian Y., Guo Y. Investigation of the splashing phenomenon of large droplets for aviation safety. SAE Technical Paper, 2015, pp. 2015-01-2100.
  33. Cao Y., Tan W., Wu Z. Aircraft icing: An ongoing threat to aviation safety. Aerospace Science and Technology, 2018, vol. 75, pp. 353–385.
  34. Isaac G.A., Cober S.G., Strapp J.W. et al. Recent Canadian research on aircraft in-flight icing. National Research Council Canada, 2001, vol. 47, pp. 213–221.
  35. Zhu D., Zhao C., Liu H. New ice accretion model for aircraft icing based on phase-field method. Applied Sciences, 2021, vol. 11, p. 5693.
  36. Wang Y., Dandekar R., Bustos N. et al. Universal Rim Thickness in Unsteady Sheet Fragmentation. Physical review letters, 2018, vol. 120, p. 204503.
  37. Tropea C., Schremb M., Roisman I.V. Physics of SLD Impact and Solidification. 7th European Conference for Aeronautics and Aerospace Sciences. Milan, 2017, p. 512.
  38. Wang Y., Cheng Y. New perspectives on the droplet freezing nucleation and early crystal growth mechanisms. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 2019, vol. 40, pp. 1023–1028.
  39. Sun M., Kong W., Wang F., Liu H. Impact freezing modes of supercooled droplets determined by both nucleation and icing evolution. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 2019, vol. 142, p. 118431.
  40. Xu Q., Li Z., Wang J., Wang R. Characteristics of single droplet impact on cold plate surfaces. Drying Technology, 2012, vol. 30 (15), pp. 1756–1762.
  41. Huang L., Liu Z., Liu Y. Effect of contact angle on water droplet freezing process on a cold flat surface. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science, 2012, vol. 40, pp. 74–80.
  42. Posner R., Santa M., Grundmeier G. Wet- and corrosive de-adhesion processes of water-borne epoxy film coated steel. Journal of The Electrochemical Society, 2011, vol. 158, pp. C29–C35.
  43. Sun J., Gong J., Li G. A lattice Boltzmann model for solidification of water droplet on cold flat plate. International Journal of Refrigeration, 2015, vol. 59, pp. 53–64.
  44. Chaudhary G., Li R. Freezing of water droplets on solid surfaces: An experimental and numerical study. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science, 2014, vol. 57, pp. 86–93.
  45. Zhang X., Wu X., Min J. Freezing and melting of a sessile water droplet on a horizontal cold plate. Experimental Thermal and Fluid Science, 2017, vol. 88, pp. 1–7.
  46. Lei G.-L., Dong W., Zheng M. et al. Numerical investigation on heat transfer and melting process of ice with different porosities. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 2017, vol. 107, pp. 934–944.
  47. Ryzhkin I.A., Petrenko V.F. Physical mechanisms responsible for ice adhesion. Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1997, vol. 101, pp. 6267–6270.
  48. Wilen L.A., Wettlaufer J.S., Elbaum M., Schick M. Dispersion-force effects in interfacial premelting of ice. Physical review, 1995, vol. 52, pp. 12426–12433.
  49. Hao P., Lv C., Zhang X. Freezing of sessile water droplets on surfaces with various roughness and wettability. Applied Physics Letters, 2014, vol. 104 (16), p. 161609.
  50. Pervier M.L.A., Lerma L.G., Moncholi P.M., Hammond D.W. A new test apparatus to measure the adhesive shear strength of impact ice on titanium 6Al–4V alloy. Engineering Fracture Mechanics, 2019, vol. 214, pp. 212–222.
  51. Attarzadeh R., Dolatabadi A. Icephobic performance of superhydrophobic coatings: A numerical analysis. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 2019, vol. 136, pp. 1327–1337.
  52. Wang C., Chang S., Leng M. et al. A two-dimensional splashing model for investigating impingement characteristics of supercooled large droplets. International Journal of Multiphase Flow, 2015, vol. 12, pp. 2–51.
  53. Zhang X., Min J., Wu X. Model for aircraft icing with consideration of property-variable rime ice. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 2016, vol. 97, pp. 185–190.
  54. Zhang X., Wu X., Min J. Aircraft icing model considering both rime ice property variability and runback water effect. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 2017, vol. 104, pp. 510–516.
  55. Zhang X., Liu X., Wu X., Min J. Impacting-freezing dynamics of a supercooled water droplet on a cold surface: Rebound and adhesion. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 2020, vol. 158, p. 119997.
  56. Jin Z., Sui D., Yang Z. The impact, freezing, and melting processes of a water droplet on an inclined cold surface. International Journal of Heat and Mass Transfer, 2015, vol. 90, pp. 439–453.
  57. Meuler A.J., Smith J.D., Varanasi K.K. et al. Relationships between Water Wettability and Ice Adhesion. ACS Applied Materials & Interfaces, 2010, vol. 2 (11), pp. 3100–3110.
  58. Tong W., Xiong D., Wang N. et al. Mechanically robust superhydrophobic coating for aeronautical composite against ice accretion and ice adhesion. Composites. Part B: Engineering, 2019, p. 107267.
  59. Sivakumar G., Jackson J., Ceylan H., Sundararajan S. Effect of plasticizer on the wear behavior and ice adhesion of elastomeric coatings. Wear, 2019, vol. 426–427, рart A, pp. 212–218.
  60. Wang C., Zhang W., Siva A. et al. Laboratory test for ice adhesion strength using commercial instrumentation. Langmuir, 2014, vol. 30, pp. 540–547.
  61. Susoff M., Siegmann K., Pfaffenroth C., Hirayama M. Evaluation of icephobic coatings – Screening of different coatings and influence of roughness. Applied Surface Science, 2013, vol. 282, pp. 870–879.
  62. Bharathidasan T., Kumar S.V., Bobji M. et al. Effect of wettability and surface roughness on ice-adhesion strength of hydrophilic, hydrophobic and superhydrophobic surfaces. Applied Surface Science, 2014, vol. 314, pp. 241–250.
  63. Douglass R.G., Palacios J.L. Effects of strain rate variation on the shear adhesion strength of impact ice. Cold Regions Science and Technology, 2021, vol. 181, p. 103168.
  64. Höhne S., Hoch C., Böhm C. et al. A new measuring system for the determination of the ice adhesion strength on smooth surfaces. Langmuir, 2020, vol. 36 (16), pp. 4465–4476.
  65. Douglas R.G., Palacios J., Schneeberger G. Design, fabrication, calibration, and testing of a centrifugal ice adhesion test rig with strain rate control capability. Proceedings of the 2018 Atmospheric and Space Environments Conference. Atlanta, 2018, p. 3342.
  66. Zhang Z., Hu H., Bai X., Hu H. An experimental study on the detrimental effects of deicing fluids on the performance of icephobic coatings for aircraft icing mitigation. Aerospace Science and Technology, 2021, vol. 119, p. 107090.
  67. Shah H., Moncholi E.P., Hong-hu J., Hammond D.W. Determination of ice adhesion and ice properties in order to determine ice shedding procedure of coating systems. 14th International Workshop on Atmospheric Icing of Structures. Chongqing, 2011, pp. 1–6.
  68. Palacios A.M., Palacios J.L., Sánchez L. Eliciting a human understandable model of ice adhesion strength for rotor blade leading edge materials from uncertain experimental data. Expert Systems with Applications, 2012, vol. 39 (11), pp. 10212–10225.
  69. Palacio J.L., Han Y., Brouwers E.W., Smith E.C. Icing environment rotor test stand liquidwater content measurement procedures and ice shape correlation. Journal of the American Helicopter Society, 2002, vol. 57 (2), p. 22006.
  70. Zheng Q., Lv J., Zhang J., Feng J. Fabrication and application of icephobic silicone coatings on epoxy substrate. Progress in Organic Coatings, 2021, vol. 161, p. 106483.
  71. Carreño F., Gude M.R., Calvo S. et al. Design and development of icephobic coatings based on sol-gel/modified polyurethane paints. Materials Today Communications, 2020, vol. 25, pp. 101616.
  72. Kondrashov S.V., Pykhtin A.A., Solovyanchik L.V., Bolshakov V.A., Pavlyuk B.Ph., Badamshina E.R., Dzhalmukhanova A.S., Karpov S.V. Research of dependence of adhesion of ice to polyurethane coatings from their physicomechanical properties. Trudy VIAM, 2019, no. 3 (75), paper no. 10. Available at: http://www.viam-works.ru (accessed: March 19, 2022). DOI: 10.18577/2307-6046-2019-0-3-87-95.
  73. Drinberg A.S., Tarasova I.N., Nedvedsky G.R. Paintwork materials with reduced adhesion to ice. LKM i ikh primenenie, 2021, no. 3, pp. 16–19.
  74. Mirshahidi K., Alasvand Zarasvand K., Luo W., Golovin K. A high throughput tensile ice adhesion measurement system. HardwareX, 2020, vol. 8, p. e00146.
  75. Boinovich L.B., Emelyanenko K.A., Emelyanenko A.M. Superhydrophobic versus SLIPS: Temperature dependence and the stability of ice adhesion strength. Journal of Colloid and Interface Science, 2021, vol. 606, pp. 556–566.
  76. Schneeberger G.M., Kozlowski R., Wolfe D., Palacios J.L. Development of a durable ice protective coating for use on rotorcraft. Cold Regions Science and Technology, 2020, vol. 193, p. 103427.
  77. Yang S., Xia Q., Zhu L. Research on the icephobic properties of fluoropolymer-based materials. Applied Surface Science, 2011, vol. 257 (11), pp. 4956–4962.
  78. Rönneberg S., Zhuo Y., Laforte C. et al. Interlaboratory Study of Ice Adhesion Using Different Techniques. Coatings, 2019, vol. 9 (10), p. 678.
  79. Woll T.R. Ice Adhesion analysis of severely aged PDMS rubbers: M.S. Thesis. University of Denver, 2018, 79 p. Available at: https://digitalcommons.du.edu/etd/1504/ (accessed: March 19, 2022).